The debate over cloth versus disposable diapers has been going on for many years and will probably continue for many more.
You may already know about some of the many benefits to cloth diapers, but we've compiled a list below for your information. . .
just in case you haven't heard about ALL the benefits yet!
Both types of diapers, cloth and disposable, have an environmental impact. Each require resources to make, each require resources to deliver diapers to the consumer and each
require some form of "disposal" (for cloth diapers this means washing and drying and for disposable diapers this means tossing them into the trash).
We have not been able to find one source which provides an un-biased report of the true cost of each option, so below we've compiled environmental facts to each side of the
debate so that you can make up your own mind.
Cloth Diapers vs. Disposable Diapers. . . Round 1
| Consideration |
Cloth Diaper |
Disposable Diaper |
| Resources required in manufacturing |
Cloth diapers, most often made from cotton, use about 30lbs of cotton per 6 dozen diapers. Although a natural substance, cotton does require
large amounts of water and pesticides. The environmental impact of cotton production can be reduced by selecting diapers made from organic cotton, bambo or hemp.
|
1 billion trees are used diaper production each year in North America. In Canada alone, 75.5 million pounds of paper goes into the production of 1.7 billion
disposable diapers. Now paper products come from a renewable resource; however, common practice when harvesting this resource usually involves clear cutting which
destroys enormous numbers of ecosystems versus selective harvesting which would have less negative impact on the ecosystems.
|
| Waste water |
Water waste created from the production of cotton may contain pesticides if not grown organically. As it is recommended to use biodegradable
detergents for washing your cloth diapers, the water from your washing machine is generally hazardous. Waste water can be reduced by using an EnergySmart front
loading washing machine (these use about 50% less water than top loading) or by selecting appropriate water levels depending on your load size.
|
Water waste created from the production of pulp, paper, and plastics used in disposable diapers contains harmful ingredients such as dioxins, sludge, solvents, and heavy metals. |
| Petroleum |
Many cloth diapers do not contain any petroleum products. However, plastic snaps, Velcro and water proof covers are made from petroleum. To put this into
perspective, the amount used for the snaps and Velcro is quite small and you do not use nearly as many waterproof covers as disposable diapers, so the total
amount of petroleum used is much less than with disposable diapers.
|
A valuable, non-renewable and diminishing resource, petroleum, is used to produce the plastic in the disposable diaper and in the packaging. 3.5 billon gallons of oil
are used to produce 18 million disposable diapers each year.
|
| Time to decompose |
From 6 months for standard cotton diapers, and longer for diapers with other materials. |
It is estimated that it will take over 500 years in a landfill when buried airtight. |
| Sewage Treatment |
Sewage is properly treated in approved treatment facilities/systems as feces are flushed down toilets and urine is removed during washing. |
Sewage treatment. . .what sewage treatment? The diapers make it to our landfills where the untreated sewage is prone to leach contaminant and possibly disease.
In fact, dumping human waste into landfills violates World Health Organization guidelines.
|
| Volume of garbage |
Negotiable. Once you finish using your cloth diapers for one baby, you can either use them again for another child, sell or give them to someone else to use,
or if they are prefold or contours, turn them into dusting/cleaning rags. Eventually when the cloth diaper has been used to the max and it makes it to an
landfill it will breakdown much more quickly than disposable diapers. The amount of garbage entering our landfills due to cloth diapers is extremely low
(mind you less than 10% of Canadian families are currently using cloth diapers).
|
Huge! Assuming each baby uses at least 6000 diapers over his/her first 2-3 years, this results in 2 ½ tonnes of waste per child added to our landfills.
With more than 90% of Canadian families using disposable diapers, we throw away 1.7 billion disposable diapers every year. Diapers account for 2% of solid waste
(or 30% of total non-biodegradable waster) in our landfills.
|
These figures are based upon using one of the products we carry, Bum Genius One-Size Pocket Diaper sold at bulk retail price ($22.85/each).
This scenario also takes into account washing diapers every second day and the child being toilet trained by 2 years old.
Based on purchasing diapers at Walmart and in the largest sized bags available per size (NB diapers cost $0.35/diaper while other sizes cost approx. $0.23/diaper).
This does not include transportation to/from the store every time you buy another package or the costs of garbage disposal. We also assumed potty training to occur ½ year later at
age 2 ½ years old as babies in cloth diapers often potty train earlier than babies in disposable diapers.
How much is it going to cost you and how much can you save?. . .find out below with an automatic calculator which allows you to input the variables.